Cimientos Económicos
  • Blog
  • Notas de Clase
  • Investigación
  • About

Determinants of the Potential Demand for Microcredit in Argentina

8/10/2016

0 Comentarios

 
Publicado en Latin American and Caribbean Economic Association - 07-10-2016
Imagen

The housing credit as well as the productive credit, increase employment, investment, productivity and the long term growth rate of the economy, and under certain conditions, contributes to alleviating poverty. This is because access to credit promotes equality of opportunities, smoothes the consumption over time and allows the reallocation of resources to more efficient uses. In this sense, microfinance has proven to be an effective mechanism of poverty reduction and for promotion of social inclusion, although it has not been a sufficient condition to achieve those objectives.
 
As known, the lower income workers hold more precarious and unstable jobs, have no collateral, and have greater vulnerability to inflation and other conditions of macroeconomic instability. That why they may be credit rationed due to these drawbacks and to market imperfections that affect both supply and demand.
 
From Argentina’s perspective, comparing the recent experience with the one of other countries in the region, we find that local microfinance sector is underdeveloped and limited to microcredit. This featured is motivated by the existence of certain obstacles. Among these hurdles there are: market failures associated with asymmetric information, insufficient or lack of funding for institutions that provide microcredit, the discriminatory tax treatment to informal micro-borrowers, relatively high labor costs faced by microfinance institutions, the little or none regulation of entities operating in the sector, lack of collateral or guarantees, and high operating costs incurred by microfinance institutions (hereinafter MFI) to monitor the loans.
 
To our knowledge, the information about the true size of the argentine microfinance market is scant or non-existent, due to a limited knowledge of the demand among other reasons. Although previous studies attempted to provide estimates about this demand, they are outdated, have been discontinued in time or suffer from some methodological shortcomings. In this sense, a central problem of the microfinance market in Argentina is the failure of MFIs to expand and reach out their demand. And that is due precisely to the limited knowledge about the actual and particularly the potential demand they face.
 
In our paper, we try to fill that gap in the literature and based on household surveys[1] we estimate the determinants of the probability of prospective microcredit demand. More specifically, we quantify, characterize and enquire about the extent in which urban households socio-economic and demographic characteristics influence in people’s propensity to ask for a microcredit, either for productive purpose or housing.
 
We contribute to the literature on financial inclusion and microfinance in developing countries in at least three respects: First, It is the first study on the determinants of the prospective demand for microcredit in Argentina using binary econometric estimation techniques (Logit). Second, we explain the prospective behavior of such demand in contrast to the overwhelming amount of literature that focuses on past demand or a broader access to financial services, including microcredit. And third, we separate out potential demand for productive microcredit from housing microcredit, unlike previous literature. The latter is based on the vast unmet demand for housing microfinance observed in Argentina.
 
We arrived at the following conclusions:
 
• We found a total of 2.080.187 individuals earning two or less minimum wages (i.e. the potential demand) that would "request a housing loan, consumption or a productive venture in the next 12 months”. From these individuals, 10% are unemployed, 45% are informal employees and 45% are formal employees.
 
• The potential demand is highly concentrated: 53% of it is located in the Greater Buenos Aires area. That proportion goes up to 77 % when including the urban areas of Córdoba, Rosario and Tucuman.
 
• The proportion of potential applicants for microcredit with access to banking services does not exceed 40%.
 
• Most of the potential applicants for housing credit are already owners (57%) living in houses (86%). The use of microcredit, in perspective, we conjecture would serve to expand or renovate an existing home or building "social" housing in the best of cases.
 
• Through our econometric estimation, we found that the main factor determining whether the person would request a microcredit next year is the occupation (if the person is employed and the type of employment). In this sense, the hypothesis that the greater the informality of the current occupation, the greater the probability of seeking a productive microcredit was confirmed.
 
• The propensity to apply for a microcredit is independent of the educational level attained by the respondent of the survey and age is positively related to the probability of applying for a microcredit although decreasing mode when the life cycle progresses.
 
• At the same time, we note that the purpose of microcredit is essential to understand the demand. For instance, women show less marginal propensity to apply for productive microcredits than men, counterintuitive of the popular belief about "social micro-entrepreneurial woman".
 
• Last, the fact that the person has applied for and obtained a loan the previous year is related to the propensity to borrow next year. However, this result is consistent with the pattern of demand for housing credit, not that of demand for productive purposes.
 
Based on the results of this research, one final corollary will be that policies of encourage or access to microcredit must be differentiated according to kind of loan. Particularly for Argentina should contemplate the local appetite to repair, expand or finish a house in order to improve living conditions and social welfare accordingly.
 

[1] Based on the data gathered from Social Debt Survey of the Catholic University Argentina 2011, a stratified sample of 5.713 housing in urban areas across the country
​
Bibliography
Carballo, I.; Grandes, M. y Molouny, L. (2016). Determinantes de la demanda potencial de microcrédito en Argentina. Cuadernos de Administración, 29 (52), 199-228. http://dx.doi.org/10.11144/ Javeriana.cao29-52.cddp
​

Ignacio E. Carballo - Martín Grandes - Luis Molouny

0 Comentarios

A simple overview of Argentina's economy before the presidential elections

19/6/2015

0 Comentarios

 
Argentina is on the transition to a new government on December 2015. Currently, there is no certainty about a radical change of the political economy.

Our economy left behind the economic growth rates of around 8%-9% which had over the period 2003-2008. Roughly, Argentina's economy has slowed down since 2011 to these days, having decreased their rates of economic growth to a 2.9% for 2013 and went into recession in 2014 with a 0.5% GDP growth. Today, the economy is weak and the inflation is high.

In 2014, the inflation rate was over 30% for privates (and for some of them closer to 40%), and around a 25% for the official statistics. This context has generated a drop in household purchasing power (affected by the drop in real wages due to the acceleration of inflation). At the same time, inflationary pressures are constant as a consequence of the expansion of the money supply which has been expanded at an average annual rate of 25% since 2003 to date (mainly, because of the assistance of the Central Bank to the Treasury). In conclusion, a sharp drop in consumption and a sharp increase in public spending.

About the external situation, exports to Brazil (main trading partner, which buys more than a fifth of our exports) are being affected as a result of lean economic development in this country and the corresponding depreciation of its currency making more expensive foreign purchases as we mentioned here. In addition to this, the European Union (approximately 13% of our exports) and the United States (approx. 6%-7%) continue to show signs of recovery while China (approx. 7%) appears to slow it´s economic growth. The challenge in this regard is to boost export relations with new partners (or with the old ones that are growing again). And to reverse the deficit position in the trade balance with the four major partners (Either increase the quantities and diversification of exports.)

GDP quarterly performance of major trading partners and Argentine participation in international trade

Imagen

Source: own calculations based on http://www.tradingeconomics.com/ and INDEC

However, the drop in the commodities prices in international markets has been affecting exports since 2014 (mainly agricultural ones). In this sense, the trade balance has presented constant yearly declines from 2010 onwards. During the year 2014, compared to 2013, the decline was 70%. This situation is complemented by the drop in industrial exports (particularly to Brazil). The current account deficit shows similar conditions. The direct consequence of this fact, is that it makes more difficult to obtain dollars, which makes the Government must apply regulatory measures in the foreign exchange market as well as controls to exports and imports (as the restrictions on dollar purchases since November 2011).

Sustained drop in commodity prices since 2011, accelerating from 2014

Imagen

Source: http://www.crbtrader.com/

In spite of attracting international currencies, all these restrictions make it less attractive for both, domestic and foreign investment. There is a mediocre business environment (124th in the Doing Business ranking prepared by the World Bank Group). In this sense, investment has fallen nearly 5.6% in 2014 compared to 2013, and industrial activity takes 21 months of consecutive decline (until April 2015). 

Looking ahead, major changes are not expected, at least until the elections in October. However, there are some threats and weaknesses which are a constant and must be reviewed by a future policy agenda. Regarding to this, we can mention: combat high inflation; regulate the assistance of the Central Bank and ANSES to the Treasury; get a budgetary policy wise, lax and with an efficient public expenditure; revert the inefficient investment in energy and transport; adjust the public subsidies; revert the fact that the State haven’t had access to international financial markets since 2001; and revert the (still) high dependence on the prices of agricultural commodities.

According to this, the post-elections agenda will remain intact and tasks will be waiting to be performed.

Ignacio E. Carballo

0 Comentarios

      Subscríbase a Cimientos Económicos

    Enviar

    Publicaciones

    Diciembre 2020
    Noviembre 2020
    Octubre 2020
    Septiembre 2020
    Agosto 2020
    Julio 2020
    Junio 2020
    Mayo 2020
    Abril 2020
    Marzo 2020
    Febrero 2020
    Enero 2020
    Diciembre 2019
    Noviembre 2019
    Octubre 2019
    Septiembre 2019
    Agosto 2019
    Junio 2019
    Mayo 2019
    Abril 2019
    Marzo 2019
    Febrero 2019
    Enero 2019
    Diciembre 2018
    Noviembre 2018
    Octubre 2018
    Septiembre 2018
    Agosto 2018
    Julio 2018
    Junio 2018
    Mayo 2018
    Abril 2018
    Marzo 2018
    Febrero 2018
    Enero 2018
    Diciembre 2017
    Noviembre 2017
    Octubre 2017
    Septiembre 2017
    Agosto 2017
    Julio 2017
    Junio 2017
    Mayo 2017
    Abril 2017
    Marzo 2017
    Febrero 2017
    Enero 2017
    Diciembre 2016
    Noviembre 2016
    Octubre 2016
    Septiembre 2016
    Agosto 2016
    Julio 2016
    Junio 2016
    Abril 2016
    Marzo 2016
    Enero 2016
    Diciembre 2015
    Noviembre 2015
    Octubre 2015
    Septiembre 2015
    Agosto 2015
    Julio 2015
    Junio 2015

    Categorías

    Todos
    Brasil
    Causalidad
    CCTs
    China
    Competitividad
    Conditional Cash Transfers
    Coyuntura
    Demanda Potencial
    Deuda Externa
    Divisas
    Economia Argentina
    Economía Argentina
    Endeudamiento
    Evaluacion De Impacto
    Financial Inclusion
    Fondos Buitres
    Genero
    Género
    Griesa
    Inclusión Financiera
    Instituciones
    Liderazgo
    Mercosur
    Microfinanzas
    Mujeres
    Pro.Cre.Ar.
    TMCs
    Transferencias Monetarias Condicionadas
    Vivienda